| 1. Sarah J. Pettyjohn, b. 1843, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States d. Yes, date unknown | | 2. Benjamin Pettyjohn, b. 1845, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States d. Yes, date unknown | | 3. William A. Pettyjohn, b. 19 Sep 1849, , , Delaware, United States d. 13 Jun 1938, Georgetown Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States (Age 88 years)
| | 4. Myers Reynolds Pettyjohn, b. 1 Jun 1856, , , Delaware, United States d. 21 Apr 1941, Rehoboth, Sussex, Delaware, United States (Age 84 years)
| | 5. Mary Pettyjohn, b. Abt 1859, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States d. Yes, date unknown | | 6. Susan Pettyjohn, b. Abt 1861, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States d. Yes, date unknown | | 7. Truitt W. Pettyjohn, b. 14 Mar 1862, , Sussex, Delaware, United States d. 22 Sep 1922, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States (Age 60 years) | | 8. David Pettyjohn, b. Abt 1865, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States d. Yes, date unknown | | 9. Margaret Pettyjohn, b. Abt 1866, Indian River Hundred, Sussex, Delaware, United States d. Yes, date unknown | |